{"schema":"fapes.inter-rater-protocol.v1","generatedAt":"2026-06-09T14:59:11.545Z","version":"v0-pre-proposta","objective":"Demonstrar, antes da proposta, como a ferramenta mede consistencia entre avaliadores, identifica divergencias e aciona recalibracao metodologica.","sourceSuiteEndpoint":"/api/validations/suite","validationEvidenceLevel":"synthetic_pre_proposal","canClaimOfficialValidation":false,"officialValidationRequired":true,"tolerance":1,"reviewerProfiles":[{"id":"technical_conservative","label":"Especialista tecnico conservador","role":"technical_specialist","stance":"conservative","expectedContribution":"Questionar TRL inflado quando a evidencia ainda e de bancada, laboratorio ou dado simulado."},{"id":"methodology_reviewer","label":"Revisor metodologico","role":"methodology_reviewer","stance":"evidence_first","expectedContribution":"Verificar reprodutibilidade, MRL/SRL, citações e coerencia entre resposta e evidencia."},{"id":"portfolio_manager","label":"Gestor de portfolio CT&I","role":"portfolio_manager","stance":"transfer_oriented","expectedContribution":"Avaliar transferencia, sustentabilidade, impacto institucional e comparabilidade entre linhas."}],"protocolSteps":[{"id":"sample_selection","label":"Selecionar amostra calibrada","execution":"Usar casos simulados de inovacao, pesquisa e extensao com gabarito TRL/BRL e evidencia citavel.","acceptanceEvidence":"/api/validations/suite"},{"id":"parallel_review","label":"Executar avaliacao paralela","execution":"Ferramenta e tres perfis de avaliador atribuem TRL/BRL sem alterar a rubrica publicada.","acceptanceEvidence":"/api/proposal/inter-rater-protocol"},{"id":"agreement_metrics","label":"Calcular Kappa/ICC","execution":"Gerar Cohen kappa, Fleiss kappa, ICC e aderencia por tolerancia para o Plano de Teste M8/M9.","acceptanceEvidence":"/api/proposal/inter-rater-protocol?format=md"},{"id":"calibration_loop","label":"Registrar divergencias e decisao humana","execution":"Casos com spread alto entram como pauta de calibracao; casos consensuais viram treinamento.","acceptanceEvidence":"Tabela de divergencias e topicos de calibracao"}],"officialValidationGates":[{"id":"authorized_sample","label":"Amostra oficial autorizada","status":"pending_cpsi","requiredEvidence":"Lista de projetos reais ou amostra autorizada pela FAPES/CTF, sem dados sigilosos indevidos."},{"id":"identified_reviewers","label":"Avaliadores reais identificados","status":"pending_cpsi","requiredEvidence":"No mínimo 3 avaliadores reais com nome, perfil, organização, e-mail e aceite."},{"id":"signed_independent_scores","label":"Notas independentes assinadas","status":"pending_cpsi","requiredEvidence":"TRL/BRL, justificativa e evidência citável registrados por avaliador antes da consolidação."},{"id":"ctf_acceptance","label":"Aceite CTF/FAPES da calibração","status":"pending_cpsi","requiredEvidence":"Ata, despacho, e-mail oficial ou documento de aceite da calibração M1/M8."}],"cases":[{"caseId":"vs-innovation-saas-operacao-assistida","title":"SaaS com API em operacao assistida","area":"innovation","kind":"straightforward","toolTrl":6,"toolBrl":4.5,"expectedTrl":6,"expectedBrl":4.5,"reviewerScores":[{"reviewerId":"technical_conservative","expertTrl":6,"expertBrl":4.5,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado."},{"reviewerId":"methodology_reviewer","expertTrl":6,"expertBrl":4.5,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado."},{"reviewerId":"portfolio_manager","expertTrl":6,"expertBrl":4.5,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura orientada a transferencia, impacto e comparabilidade institucional."}],"disagreementSeverity":"none","calibrationTopic":"Usar como exemplo positivo de consenso entre ferramenta e avaliadores."},{"caseId":"vs-innovation-lab-borderline","title":"Inovacao em laboratorio no limite TRL 4","area":"innovation","kind":"borderline","toolTrl":4,"toolBrl":3,"expectedTrl":4,"expectedBrl":3,"reviewerScores":[{"reviewerId":"technical_conservative","expertTrl":4,"expertBrl":3,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Caso de borda para discutir limite entre laboratorio, ambiente relevante e transferencia."},{"reviewerId":"methodology_reviewer","expertTrl":4,"expertBrl":3,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Caso de borda para discutir limite entre laboratorio, ambiente relevante e transferencia."},{"reviewerId":"portfolio_manager","expertTrl":5,"expertBrl":3,"trlDelta":1,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Caso de borda para discutir limite entre laboratorio, ambiente relevante e transferencia."}],"disagreementSeverity":"moderate","calibrationTopic":"Registrar justificativa de calibracao e manter exemplo como caso de treinamento."},{"caseId":"vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence","title":"TRL alto declarado com evidencia apenas laboratorial","area":"innovation","kind":"contradictory","toolTrl":5,"toolBrl":3,"expectedTrl":5,"expectedBrl":3,"reviewerScores":[{"reviewerId":"technical_conservative","expertTrl":3,"expertBrl":2,"trlDelta":2,"brlDelta":1,"withinTolerance":false,"notes":"Divergencia proposital: evidencia laboratorial nao sustenta TRL operacional sem revisao humana."},{"reviewerId":"methodology_reviewer","expertTrl":3,"expertBrl":3,"trlDelta":2,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":false,"notes":"Divergencia proposital: evidencia laboratorial nao sustenta TRL operacional sem revisao humana."},{"reviewerId":"portfolio_manager","expertTrl":4,"expertBrl":3,"trlDelta":1,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Divergencia proposital: evidencia laboratorial nao sustenta TRL operacional sem revisao humana."}],"disagreementSeverity":"high","calibrationTopic":"Definir regra explicita para impedir TRL 7+ quando a unica evidencia e laboratorio/dado simulado."},{"caseId":"vs-research-reproducible-bench","title":"Pesquisa de bancada reprodutivel","area":"research","kind":"straightforward","toolTrl":4,"toolBrl":3,"expectedTrl":4,"expectedBrl":3,"reviewerScores":[{"reviewerId":"technical_conservative","expertTrl":4,"expertBrl":3,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado."},{"reviewerId":"methodology_reviewer","expertTrl":4,"expertBrl":3,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado."},{"reviewerId":"portfolio_manager","expertTrl":4,"expertBrl":3,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura orientada a transferencia, impacto e comparabilidade institucional."}],"disagreementSeverity":"none","calibrationTopic":"Usar como exemplo positivo de consenso entre ferramenta e avaliadores."},{"caseId":"vs-research-transfer-ready","title":"Pesquisa aplicada com transferencia encaminhada","area":"research","kind":"straightforward","toolTrl":5,"toolBrl":4,"expectedTrl":5,"expectedBrl":4,"reviewerScores":[{"reviewerId":"technical_conservative","expertTrl":5,"expertBrl":4,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado."},{"reviewerId":"methodology_reviewer","expertTrl":5,"expertBrl":4,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado."},{"reviewerId":"portfolio_manager","expertTrl":5,"expertBrl":4,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura orientada a transferencia, impacto e comparabilidade institucional."}],"disagreementSeverity":"none","calibrationTopic":"Usar como exemplo positivo de consenso entre ferramenta e avaliadores."},{"caseId":"vs-extension-community-mature","title":"Extensao com comunidade e indicadores maduros","area":"extension","kind":"straightforward","toolTrl":6,"toolBrl":4,"expectedTrl":6,"expectedBrl":4,"reviewerScores":[{"reviewerId":"technical_conservative","expertTrl":6,"expertBrl":4,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado."},{"reviewerId":"methodology_reviewer","expertTrl":6,"expertBrl":4,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado."},{"reviewerId":"portfolio_manager","expertTrl":6,"expertBrl":4,"trlDelta":0,"brlDelta":0,"withinTolerance":true,"notes":"Leitura orientada a transferencia, impacto e comparabilidade institucional."}],"disagreementSeverity":"none","calibrationTopic":"Usar como exemplo positivo de consenso entre ferramenta e avaliadores."}],"syntheticValidationRecords":[{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-innovation-saas-operacao-assistida-technical_conservative","assessmentId":"assess-vs-innovation-saas-operacao-assistida-fapes-v1.0-innovation","projectId":"vs-innovation-saas-operacao-assistida","projectTitle":"SaaS com API em operacao assistida","area":"innovation","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":6,"expertTrl":6,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":4.5,"expertBrl":4.5,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"technical_conservative","notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado.","recordedAt":"2026-05-27T09:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-innovation-saas-operacao-assistida-methodology_reviewer","assessmentId":"assess-vs-innovation-saas-operacao-assistida-fapes-v1.0-innovation","projectId":"vs-innovation-saas-operacao-assistida","projectTitle":"SaaS com API em operacao assistida","area":"innovation","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":6,"expertTrl":6,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":4.5,"expertBrl":4.5,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"methodology_reviewer","notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado.","recordedAt":"2026-05-27T10:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-innovation-saas-operacao-assistida-portfolio_manager","assessmentId":"assess-vs-innovation-saas-operacao-assistida-fapes-v1.0-innovation","projectId":"vs-innovation-saas-operacao-assistida","projectTitle":"SaaS com API em operacao assistida","area":"innovation","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":6,"expertTrl":6,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":4.5,"expertBrl":4.5,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"portfolio_manager","notes":"Leitura orientada a transferencia, impacto e comparabilidade institucional.","recordedAt":"2026-05-27T11:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-innovation-lab-borderline-technical_conservative","assessmentId":"assess-vs-innovation-lab-borderline-fapes-v1.0-innovation","projectId":"vs-innovation-lab-borderline","projectTitle":"Inovacao em laboratorio no limite TRL 4","area":"innovation","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":4,"expertTrl":4,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":3,"expertBrl":3,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"technical_conservative","notes":"Caso de borda para discutir limite entre laboratorio, ambiente relevante e transferencia.","recordedAt":"2026-05-28T09:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-innovation-lab-borderline-methodology_reviewer","assessmentId":"assess-vs-innovation-lab-borderline-fapes-v1.0-innovation","projectId":"vs-innovation-lab-borderline","projectTitle":"Inovacao em laboratorio no limite TRL 4","area":"innovation","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":4,"expertTrl":4,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":3,"expertBrl":3,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"methodology_reviewer","notes":"Caso de borda para discutir limite entre laboratorio, ambiente relevante e transferencia.","recordedAt":"2026-05-28T10:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-innovation-lab-borderline-portfolio_manager","assessmentId":"assess-vs-innovation-lab-borderline-fapes-v1.0-innovation","projectId":"vs-innovation-lab-borderline","projectTitle":"Inovacao em laboratorio no limite TRL 4","area":"innovation","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":4,"expertTrl":5,"trlDelta":1,"toolBrl":3,"expertBrl":3,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"portfolio_manager","notes":"Caso de borda para discutir limite entre laboratorio, ambiente relevante e transferencia.","recordedAt":"2026-05-28T11:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence-technical_conservative","assessmentId":"assess-vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence-fapes-v1.0-innovation","projectId":"vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence","projectTitle":"TRL alto declarado com evidencia apenas laboratorial","area":"innovation","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":5,"expertTrl":3,"trlDelta":2,"toolBrl":3,"expertBrl":2,"brlDelta":1,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":false,"evaluator":"technical_conservative","notes":"Divergencia proposital: evidencia laboratorial nao sustenta TRL operacional sem revisao humana.","recordedAt":"2026-05-29T09:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence-methodology_reviewer","assessmentId":"assess-vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence-fapes-v1.0-innovation","projectId":"vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence","projectTitle":"TRL alto declarado com evidencia apenas laboratorial","area":"innovation","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":5,"expertTrl":3,"trlDelta":2,"toolBrl":3,"expertBrl":3,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":false,"evaluator":"methodology_reviewer","notes":"Divergencia proposital: evidencia laboratorial nao sustenta TRL operacional sem revisao humana.","recordedAt":"2026-05-29T10:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence-portfolio_manager","assessmentId":"assess-vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence-fapes-v1.0-innovation","projectId":"vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence","projectTitle":"TRL alto declarado com evidencia apenas laboratorial","area":"innovation","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":5,"expertTrl":4,"trlDelta":1,"toolBrl":3,"expertBrl":3,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"portfolio_manager","notes":"Divergencia proposital: evidencia laboratorial nao sustenta TRL operacional sem revisao humana.","recordedAt":"2026-05-29T11:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-research-reproducible-bench-technical_conservative","assessmentId":"assess-vs-research-reproducible-bench-fapes-v1.0-research","projectId":"vs-research-reproducible-bench","projectTitle":"Pesquisa de bancada reprodutivel","area":"research","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":4,"expertTrl":4,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":3,"expertBrl":3,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"technical_conservative","notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado.","recordedAt":"2026-05-30T09:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-research-reproducible-bench-methodology_reviewer","assessmentId":"assess-vs-research-reproducible-bench-fapes-v1.0-research","projectId":"vs-research-reproducible-bench","projectTitle":"Pesquisa de bancada reprodutivel","area":"research","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":4,"expertTrl":4,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":3,"expertBrl":3,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"methodology_reviewer","notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado.","recordedAt":"2026-05-30T10:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-research-reproducible-bench-portfolio_manager","assessmentId":"assess-vs-research-reproducible-bench-fapes-v1.0-research","projectId":"vs-research-reproducible-bench","projectTitle":"Pesquisa de bancada reprodutivel","area":"research","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":4,"expertTrl":4,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":3,"expertBrl":3,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"portfolio_manager","notes":"Leitura orientada a transferencia, impacto e comparabilidade institucional.","recordedAt":"2026-05-30T11:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-research-transfer-ready-technical_conservative","assessmentId":"assess-vs-research-transfer-ready-fapes-v1.0-research","projectId":"vs-research-transfer-ready","projectTitle":"Pesquisa aplicada com transferencia encaminhada","area":"research","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":5,"expertTrl":5,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":4,"expertBrl":4,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"technical_conservative","notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado.","recordedAt":"2026-05-31T09:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-research-transfer-ready-methodology_reviewer","assessmentId":"assess-vs-research-transfer-ready-fapes-v1.0-research","projectId":"vs-research-transfer-ready","projectTitle":"Pesquisa aplicada com transferencia encaminhada","area":"research","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":5,"expertTrl":5,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":4,"expertBrl":4,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"methodology_reviewer","notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado.","recordedAt":"2026-05-31T10:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-research-transfer-ready-portfolio_manager","assessmentId":"assess-vs-research-transfer-ready-fapes-v1.0-research","projectId":"vs-research-transfer-ready","projectTitle":"Pesquisa aplicada com transferencia encaminhada","area":"research","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":5,"expertTrl":5,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":4,"expertBrl":4,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"portfolio_manager","notes":"Leitura orientada a transferencia, impacto e comparabilidade institucional.","recordedAt":"2026-05-31T11:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-extension-community-mature-technical_conservative","assessmentId":"assess-vs-extension-community-mature-fapes-v1.0-extension","projectId":"vs-extension-community-mature","projectTitle":"Extensao com comunidade e indicadores maduros","area":"extension","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":6,"expertTrl":6,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":4,"expertBrl":4,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"technical_conservative","notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado.","recordedAt":"2026-06-01T09:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-extension-community-mature-methodology_reviewer","assessmentId":"assess-vs-extension-community-mature-fapes-v1.0-extension","projectId":"vs-extension-community-mature","projectTitle":"Extensao com comunidade e indicadores maduros","area":"extension","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":6,"expertTrl":6,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":4,"expertBrl":4,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"methodology_reviewer","notes":"Leitura dentro da tolerancia do gabarito simulado.","recordedAt":"2026-06-01T10:00:00.000Z"},{"validationId":"val-sim-vs-extension-community-mature-portfolio_manager","assessmentId":"assess-vs-extension-community-mature-fapes-v1.0-extension","projectId":"vs-extension-community-mature","projectTitle":"Extensao com comunidade e indicadores maduros","area":"extension","rubricVersion":"fapes-v1.0-simulated","toolTrl":6,"expertTrl":6,"trlDelta":0,"toolBrl":4,"expertBrl":4,"brlDelta":0,"tolerance":1,"withinTolerance":true,"evaluator":"portfolio_manager","notes":"Leitura orientada a transferencia, impacto e comparabilidade institucional.","recordedAt":"2026-06-01T11:00:00.000Z"}],"disagreements":[{"caseId":"vs-innovation-lab-borderline","title":"Inovacao em laboratorio no limite TRL 4","dimension":"TRL","severity":"moderate","spread":1,"recommendedCalibration":"Registrar justificativa de calibracao e manter exemplo como caso de treinamento."},{"caseId":"vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence","title":"TRL alto declarado com evidencia apenas laboratorial","dimension":"TRL","severity":"high","spread":2,"recommendedCalibration":"Definir regra explicita para impedir TRL 7+ quando a unica evidencia e laboratorio/dado simulado."},{"caseId":"vs-innovation-claim-operational-with-lab-evidence","title":"TRL alto declarado com evidencia apenas laboratorial","dimension":"BRL","severity":"moderate","spread":1,"recommendedCalibration":"Definir regra explicita para impedir TRL 7+ quando a unica evidencia e laboratorio/dado simulado."}],"agreement":{"pairedSampleCount":18,"multiRaterProjectCount":6,"cohenKappa":0.68,"cohenInterpretation":"aceitável","fleissKappa":0.69,"icc":0.7,"recalibrationRequired":false,"recommendedAction":"Manter monitoramento e registrar divergências explicadas no relatório técnico."},"validationSummary":{"total":18,"withinToleranceCount":16,"outsideToleranceCount":2,"withinToleranceRate":88.9,"averageTrlDelta":0.3,"averageBrlDelta":0.1,"latestRecordedAt":"2026-06-01T11:00:00.000Z","agreement":{"pairedSampleCount":18,"multiRaterProjectCount":6,"cohenKappa":0.68,"cohenInterpretation":"aceitável","fleissKappa":0.69,"icc":0.7,"recalibrationRequired":false,"recommendedAction":"Manter monitoramento e registrar divergências explicadas no relatório técnico."}},"limitations":["Este protocolo usa avaliadores sinteticos para demonstrar o metodo; a medicao oficial depende de avaliadores reais da FAPES no CPSI.","O objetivo nao e substituir julgamento humano, e sim revelar divergencias e documentar a decisao final.","Kappa/Fleiss/ICC devem ser interpretados com cautela em amostras pequenas e sempre acompanhados de analise qualitativa."],"summary":{"reviewerCount":3,"caseCount":6,"validationRecordCount":18,"withinToleranceCount":16,"withinToleranceRate":88.9,"multiRaterProjectCount":6,"cohenKappa":0.68,"fleissKappa":0.69,"icc":0.7,"moderateDisagreementCount":2,"highDisagreementCount":1,"recalibrationRequired":false,"readyForProposal":true,"validationEvidenceLevel":"synthetic_pre_proposal","canClaimOfficialValidation":false,"officialValidationRequired":true,"officialReviewerCount":0,"officialCaseCount":0,"minimumOfficialReviewerCount":3,"minimumOfficialCaseCount":20,"officialValidationGateCount":4,"metOfficialValidationGateCount":0}}